Plot summary
Raised by poor and devoutly religious parents, who force him to participate in their street missionary work, the ambitious but immature Clyde is anxious to achieve better things. His troubles begin when he takes a job as a
bellboy at a local hotel. The boys he meets are much more sophisticated than he, and they introduce Clyde to the world of alcohol and prostitution. Clyde enjoys his new lifestyle and does everything in his power to win the affections of the flirtatious
Hortense Briggs. But Clyde's life is forever changed when a stolen car in which he's traveling kills a young child. Clyde flees
Kansas City, and after a brief stay in
Chicago, he reestablishes himself as a
foreman at the collar factory of his wealthy long-lost uncle in Lycurgus, New York, who meets Clyde through a stroke of fortune. The uncle does his best to help Clyde and advances him to a position of relative importance within the factory.
Although Clyde vows not to consort with women in the way that caused his Kansas City downfall, he is swiftly attracted to
Roberta Alden, a poor and very innocent farm girl working under him at the factory. Clyde initially enjoys the secretive relationship (forbidden by factory rules) and virtually coerces Roberta into sex, but his ambition forces him to realize that he could never marry her. He dreams of the elegant
Sondra Finchley, the daughter of a wealthy Lycurgus man and a family friend of his uncle's. As developments between he and Sondra begin to look promising, Roberta discovers that she is pregnant.
Having unsuccessfully attempted to procure an abortion for Roberta, who expects him to marry her, Clyde procrastinates while his relationship with Sondra continues to mature. When he realizes that he has a genuine chance to marry Sondra, and after Roberta threatens to reveal their relationship unless he marries her, Clyde hatches a plan to murder Roberta in a fashion that will seem accidental.
Clyde takes Roberta for a
canoe ride on
Big Bittern Lake in upstate
New York and rows to a remote area. As he speaks to her regarding the end of their relationship, Roberta moves towards him, and he strikes her in the face with his camera, stunning her and capsizing the boat. Unable to swim, Roberta drowns while Clyde, who is unwilling to save her, swims to shore. The narrative is deliberately unclear as to whether he acted with malice and intent to murder, or if he struck her merely instinctively. However, the trail of circumstantial evidence points to murder, and the local authorities are only too eager to convict Clyde, to the point of manufacturing additional evidence against him. Following a sensational trial before an unsympathetic audience, and despite a vigorous defense mounted by two lawyers hired by his uncle, Clyde is convicted, sentenced to death, and
executed. The jailhouse scenes and the correspondence between Clyde and his mother stand out as exemplars of
pathos in modern literature.
Inspiration
Dreiser based the book on a notorious criminal case. On
July 11,
1906, resort owners found an overturned boat and the body of 20-year-old
Grace Brown at
Big Moose Lake in
upstate New York.
Chester Gillette was put on trial and convicted of killing Brown, though he claimed that her death was an accident. Gillette was executed by
electric chair in 1908.
[1] The murder trial drew international attention when Brown's love letters to Gillette were read in court. Dreiser saved newspaper clippings about the case for several years before writing his novel. Clyde Griffiths was based on Chester Gillette, down to having the same initials.
In popular culture
An American Tragedy
has been adapted into
opera, at the hands of composer
Tobias Picker. It premiered at the
Metropolitan Opera starring
Nathan Gunn in New York on
December 2,
2005. The well-known
Paramount Pictures film
A Place in the Sun
(1951) is also based on
An American Tragedy
. Dreiser strongly disapproved of a 1931 film version directed by
Josef von Sternberg and also released by Paramount.
Sergei Eisenstein prepared a screenplay in the late 1920s which he hoped to have produced by Paramount or by
Charlie Chaplin during Eisenstein's stay in Hollywood in 1930. Many critics and commentators have also compared elements of
Woody Allen's film,
Match Point
(2005) to the central plot of
An American Tragedy
.
The novel inspired an episode of the award-winning
old-time radio show
Our Miss Brooks
, an episode known as "Weekend at Crystal Lake" and sometimes known as "An American Tragedy". The episode revolved around the characters' misinterpreting the intentions of biology teacher Philip Boyton (played by
Jeff Chandler), Connie Brooks's (
Eve Arden) high school colleague and love interest. The characters fear that Boynton plans to kill Miss Brooks during a leisurely weekend at their boss's lakeside retreat. The episode was broadcast twice, on
September 19,
1948, and — with very minor changes — on
August 21,
1949. The episode was also repeated in 1955, at a time the show was a hit on both radio and
television.
[2]
References
- Nelson, Randy F. ''The Almanac of American Letters''. Los Altos, California: William Kaufmann, Inc., 1981: 195–196. ISBN 086576008X
- www.vicandsade.net