| Year
| Score
| Venue
|
| 1992
| Team West 5-4 Team East
| SaskPlace, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
|
| 1993
| WHL/OHL 7-5 QMJHL
| Montreal Forum, Montreal
|
| 1994
| WHL/OHL 9-7 QMJHL
| Moncton Coliseum, Moncton, New Brunswick
|
| 1995
| WHL/QMJHL 8-3 OHL
| Kitchener Memorial Auditorium, Kitchener, Ontario
|
| 1996
| Team Cherry 9-3 Team Orr
| Maple Leaf Gardens, Toronto
|
| 1997
| Team Orr 7-2 Team Cherry
| Maple Leaf Gardens, Toronto
|
| 1998
| Team Cherry 4-2 Team Orr
| Maple Leaf Gardens, Toronto
|
| 1999
| Team Orr 4-3 Team Cherry
| Pengrowth Saddledome, Calgary, Alberta
|
| 2000
| Team Orr 6-3 Team Cherry
| Air Canada Centre, Toronto
|
| 2001
| Team Orr 5-3 Team Cherry
| Pengrowth Saddledome, Calgary, Alberta
|
| 2002
| Team Tiger 7-4 Team Hrudey
| Saskatchewan Place, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
|
| 2003
| Team Cherry 4-3 Team Orr
| Kitchener Memorial Auditorium, Kitchener, Ontario
|
| 2004
| Team Orr 6-2 Team Cherry
| John Labatt Centre, London, Ontario
|
| 2005
| Team Cherry 8-4 Team Davidson
| Pacific Coliseum, Vancouver, British Columbia
|
| 2006
| Team Orr 7-2 Team Cherry
| Scotiabank Place, Ottawa, Ontario
|
| 2007
| Team Red 5-3 Team White
| Colisée Pepsi, Quebec City, Quebec
|
| 2008
| Team White 8-4 Team Red
| Rexall Place, Edmonton, Alberta
|
| 2009
| Team Orr 6-1 Team Cherry
| General Motors Centre, Oshawa, Ontario [1]
|